Two separate repositories or a combined repository for radioactive waste?

Nagra is planning a deep geological repository for low- and intermediate-level waste and one for high-level waste – or one so-called combined repository.

Switzerland foresees disposal of radioactive waste in two repositories: one for low- and intermediate-level waste and one for high-level waste. The two repositories could be located in the same siting region as a so-called combined repository provided safety is not compromised and there is sufficient space.

The variants «two separate repositories» and «combined repository» are compared in a new report by Nagra. The focus is on impacts on the environment and on topics such as spatial requirements, waste transports, synergy effects and operational safety. Long-term safety is not addressed in the report and will be considered at a later stage.

The report reveals the following: A combined repository requires only about half (56%) of the space at the surface that two separate repositories would require. The construction volume (82%), the volume of material excavated during construction (90%) and the lower consumption of resources and energy also speak in favour of a combined repository, as do the cost advantages: A combined repository would cost around 1.6 billion Swiss Francs less than two separate repositories.

In the case of a combined repository, the ecological and socio-economic impacts are concentrated in one siting region; they are greater there and last longer than at sites for two separate repositories. The manpower requirements are lower (90%) for a combined repository than for two individual facilities. In the case of a combined repository, personnel can also be employed on site for a longer operating period, which also results in a better build-up of know-how.

Conclusion: The report shows that a combined repository would have significant advantages over two separate repositories. However, a combined repository can only be realised if long-term safety is not compromised in any way.

We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you consent to our use of cookies. For more information on our “Legal Conditions and Privacy Policy”, click here. Find out more about legal and data protection here
I accept